His point number one is totally incoherent.
#4 yes, frustrating as heck too.
#5 yes, Time Machine sucks.
Ok, so he hates the new visuals and I think they were a step in the wrong direction. Continually disconnecting from a network share is annoying, yes, I agree. And Time Machine comes up very short in function. But is it Apple's Vista? I don't think he makes enough convincing points to draw that conclusion.